Process to Challenge a Fine and Refund of Fines in Victoria.

In Victoria, if you have paid a fine and believe that the fine was contrary to law or unlawful, you may be able to claim the payment back. However, there are specific time limitations within which you must take action. This could apply to Covid Fines.

Time Limitations to Claim a Fine Payment Back in Victoria

The time limit for challenging the fine or seeking a refund will depend on the circumstances under which the fine was issued and how it was paid.

1. Challenging a Fine (Reversal or Cancellation)

If you believe the fine was issued unlawfully or is contrary to law, there are two potential avenues for challenging it:

  • Internal Review: Before seeking a refund, you can request an internal review of the fine. Many fines issued by government agencies (e.g., local councils or the State Revenue Office) allow for an internal review process where you can provide reasons why you think the fine was wrongly issued. This process is generally available within a 30-day period from the date you were issued the fine.
  • Appeal to the Magistrates' Court: If the fine was imposed in the context of a penalty notice (such as a traffic fine or council fine), you may be able to contest the fine in court. Typically, you must lodge an appeal within 28 daysof receiving the fine or penalty notice. If the fine is related to an infringement notice (e.g., parking, traffic fines), the appeal would be heard in the Magistrates' Court.

2. Seeking a Refund (Refund of Paid Fines)

If you have already paid the fine and want to claim the payment back because you believe it was unlawfully imposed or is contrary to law, the process is more complex.

  • Request for Refund: You can request a refund for a fine that was paid in error or unlawfully, but you must do so within a reasonable time after discovering the error. Generally, the government agencies involved may consider refund requests made within 6 years after the payment was made.
  • Refund of Fines under the Fines Reform: For fines paid to the Fines Victoria or the State Revenue Office (SRO), there is a statutory period within which you can request a refund. This is generally limited to 6 years from the date the payment was made. However, in cases of error or unlawful fines, a refund might be available even after this period, depending on the specific circumstances.

3. How to Request a Refund:

To claim back a fine, you typically need to:

  • Contact the Issuing Authority: If you believe the fine was issued unlawfully, the first step is to contact the agency that issued the fine (such as Fines Victoria, a local council, or the SRO) and explain your situation. You should provide reasons why you believe the fine was wrongly imposed and request a refund.
  • Provide Supporting Evidence: To support your claim, you will need to provide relevant documents (such as evidence that the fine was issued in error, contrary to law, or was paid under duress).
  • Appeal Process: If your refund request is denied, you may need to appeal the decision through an internal reviewprocess or take the matter to court.

4. Refunds of Penalty Payments (Court-Ordered Fines)

If the fine was imposed as part of a court order, you may need to apply to the court to seek a refund. The court may be able to reverse the fine, particularly if you can show that it was imposed unlawfully or in error. The time limit for seeking a refund would depend on the specific circumstances of the fine and the court's decision, but it would typically be limited to 6 years from the payment date.