In Victoria, a judicial review is a process where a court examines the legality or correctness of a decision made by a government body, tribunal, or public official. The purpose is not to review the merits of the decision, but to determine if the decision was made within the law and followed proper procedures. Here’s how you can apply for a judicial review in Victoria:
1. Identify the Decision to be Reviewed
You can seek a judicial review if you believe a decision made by a government agency, tribunal, or other public authority is unlawful or unreasonable. For example, you may challenge decisions like:
- Administrative decisions (e.g., permits, licenses, fines).
- Decisions of tribunals or regulatory bodies.
- Acts of public officials.
The decision must be something that affects your rights, interests, or legal standing.
2. Grounds for Judicial Review
A judicial review in Victoria can be sought on various grounds, including:
- Illegality: The decision-maker acted outside the scope of their legal powers.
- Procedural unfairness: The decision was made without giving you a fair hearing or following due process.
- Error of law: The decision was based on a misunderstanding or misapplication of the law.
- Unreasonableness: The decision is so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have made it (also known as "Wednesbury unreasonableness").
- Bias: The decision-maker had a conflict of interest or was biased.
3. Check the Time Limits
Judicial review applications generally must be made within 28 days of the decision being made or communicated. There are some exceptions, but it’s essential to act quickly. Delaying could mean you lose your right to apply for judicial review.
4. Consider Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
Before applying for judicial review, it’s often recommended to exhaust other available avenues, such as:
- Internal review: Many government agencies offer an internal review process where you can ask the decision-maker to reconsider their decision.
- External review: Some decisions may be subject to review by an external body, such as the Victorian Ombudsman or the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT). If you’ve exhausted these options and believe a decision is still unlawful, then judicial review may be appropriate.
5. File an Application for Judicial Review
If you decide to proceed, you will need to file an application for judicial review in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The key steps in filing include:
- Application Form: You will need to fill out an application form (Form 1) to initiate judicial review proceedings.
- Grounds for Review: You must clearly state the legal grounds on which you are seeking the judicial review.
- Supporting Documents: Attach relevant documents, such as the decision in question, any correspondence, and evidence to support your claim.
- Court Fees: There are fees for filing an application in the Supreme Court. Fees vary, so you should check the latest fee schedule on the court’s website or seek advice from a lawyer.
The application is generally filed in the Supreme Court of Victoria, either in the Trial Division or in the Court of Appeal (in certain cases). Most judicial review cases will start in the Trial Division.
6. Serve the Application
After filing, you must serve a copy of the application on the relevant government agency or authority that made the decision. They will then have an opportunity to respond to the application.
7. Hearings and Court Process
- Preliminary Hearing: The court will first determine whether the case should proceed. This is often a "leave" (permission) hearing where the judge decides whether your case has sufficient merit to continue.
- Full Hearing: If the judge grants leave, a full hearing will follow, where both parties present their arguments.
- Outcome: The court may order the decision to be:
- Quashed (invalidated) if the decision is found to be unlawful.
- Remitted (sent back) to the decision-maker for reconsideration with specific directions.
The court may also decide to award costs, although this is not automatic.
8. Legal Representation
While you can represent yourself, judicial review proceedings can be complex. It’s highly advisable to consult a lawyer who specializes in administrative law or public law to guide you through the process. Lawyers can help identify the proper grounds, prepare your application, and represent you in court.
9. Possible Outcomes of Judicial Review
If the judicial review is successful, the court may:
- Quash the decision: The decision is declared invalid.
- Order a rehearing: The decision-maker must reconsider the case, often with specific instructions from the court.
- Declare the decision lawful: If the court finds the decision was made lawfully, it may leave the decision standing.
10. Appeal
If you are unhappy with the court's decision, you may be able to appeal. The usual process for appealing a judicial review decision in Victoria involves applying to the Court of Appeal, but you must have strong grounds for an appeal.
18 pages